A Small Sampling of the Wartburg Watch Combox Regarding Al Mohler


Editors Note. This entry has existed in a previous form for several months. I have chosen to edit it because even though I believe the thrust of my concerns are legitimate, I sinfully used hyperbole and personal invectives against the two owners of the blog, as well as their commenters, in order to get my point across. A friend told me that I needed to repent and  change this and I heeded his call, so this is where I am. I could have been more gracious. I should have tried harder to “win a brother”, not provoke them to wrath. I have reached out to one of the owners and after some thought and consideration and feedback, I have decided to keep the post up, and yet edit out what I deemed sinful choice of words on my part. I’ll own my own words. I don’t believe in trying to cover any thing up, ever, and so if someone reads this and surmise I’m trying to hide what I previously have said- I’m not. If you contact me I will provide you with the original post, with this note at the top explaining the errors of my ways. 


I like Al Mohler. I don’t know him personally, but I have read most of his books, have read many of his articles, have listened to him on The Briefing, and am aware of the high esteem that the vast majority of my Christian heroes regard him with, as well as the general evangelical populace. He is considered to be a smart, thoughtful, gracious man full of integrity, conviction and Godly character, even as he is a sinful man like the rest of us.

For this reason I thought he would make an excellent candidate to demonstrate my concerns with the comment box at the Wartburg Watch– an online discernment ministry whose emphasis is topics relating to the spiritual abuse of parishioners by Christian pastors, teachers, authors and bloggers. At the Wartburg Watch, my concern is that there isn’t enough discernment applied inwardly to themselves. Often times it can feel like anyone who does not adhere to their understanding of biblical authority as it plays out in the Church and home is quickly written off, or must necessarily hold to positions that they do not hold.  This is most clearly seen in the combox, which is regulated and  moderated by the its creators who allow it to go on.

Though there have been some exceptions where people are cautioned to not go too far on some of the more extreme comments, for the most part personal attacks and insults often go unchecked and are seemingly actively encouraged. The commenters will give long, rambling detailed psychoanalysis of anyone who they feel deserve it, often by excoriating their motives and speculating and ascribing  intent heaped on with snarky and angry assertions.  In many ways it strikes me as a toxic environment, and its a shame because they often bring up something worth talking about, and address real concerns with a lot of the leaders in Christian circles, [especially the issue of spiritual abuse, which I believe needs to be given a greater voice] but the combox just kills them. Often I can’t tell if the people commenting are even Christians, because their worldview is so skewed. Perhaps there are a lot of non-Christian commenting, but it just seems to me as so much of the rhetoric is excessive and often dips into the category of sinful.

To wit, here is a small sample I’ve taken from two or three threads about Dr Al Mohler within about 10 minutes of searching which show a varied collection of slander, insults and misrepresentation of his beliefs and character. It’s important to note that these are all relatively mild compared to some of the other Christian leaders they’ve attacked [Joshua Harris, CJ Mahaney, Mark Driscoll, John Piper, Tim Challies, Anyone at TGC, Phil Johnson, RC Sproul, Any Complementarian, Any Calvinist, etc] But they serve the point that if these things are said about Al Mohler, how much worse will they say about people they really don’t like.:

[He and his friends are] “A confederacy of dunces”

[Mohler] is a despicable human being that blaspheme the name of God.”

 “They’re pathetic”

“What a false gospel and world these men promote. They fit right in with Mormons and the Taliban”

“Mohler et al are abusers of the caliber of my father. I believe this because they are doing publicly what my father did privately: deliberately insistently demeaning people at the core of their beings—in their case, women”

“Mohler only wants to indoctrinate.”

“If Mohler and Patterson lived in the South in the mid-1800′s with this same hermeneutic, they would be slave owners.”

“He doesn’t possess the ability to communicate it in any meaningful way. Read his blog, and you will see a string of superlatives (his incessant use of the words “breathtaking” and “astonishing” are nauseating), with very little actual argument or critical thinking. And his books are not written to thinkers, or even those with a reading comprehension level above maybe 4th grade”

“Mohler pretty much depicts all single adult Christians as being ‘despicable’ in explaining why he thinks it’s okay to practice discrimination in churches not hiring singles, and in blaming singles for being single (he thinks everyone should marry by 21 or 22.)”


“I do not think they are very bright. They have the same abilities as our infamous banksters: legalistically clever and savvy at turning situations to their favor. Certainly they have no wisdom, which is the best of intelligence.”

“They [Mohler et al] are false teachers”

[Mohler is the]archetype of antichrist

“I agree they are locked into teaching falsehoods and have shown no sign of openness to listening to what Christians are saying, or demonstrating any willingness to repent. Soft hearts? I’d say hardened hearts.”

“You would not know that from reading Mohler’s incredibly rude, condescending, insulting, unbiblical rhetoric against adult Christian singles.

“[Mohler et al] teach a reductionist, utilitarian view of women. They distill women (and men) down to objects that can only fill specific functions. They deny the fact that women (and men) are made in the image and likeness of God Himself. By denying this reality and truth (and yes, it’s Catholic but probably everybody here would agree to it’s truth), they deny or at least ignore Jesus’s own coming as flesh and blood which we just celebrating at Christmas (the Incarnation)”

“It just seems to me that Mohler continues to share a bed with Mahaney primarily because neither of them wants to share it with a woman.”

[Regarding Al Mohlers book] “All 25 chapters are titled with a non-biblical or twisted biblical belief Dr. Mohler has about leadership”

[Regarding Al Mohler] “That’s what I said. That’s what I call anyone who perverts the word of God to a gospel of oppression that justifies throwing people out of a job and into the street just because they lack a penis. They can twist the few verses there are out of context to try and put lipstick on their theological pig, but when Jesus says the two overriding commandments are to love God and love your neighbor and on these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets, there is no way to justify such oppression of women because that is NOT love in any sense of the word.”

“Based on how thoroughly Mohler conducted his scorched earth purges of women and ‘liberals’, I’ll bet there’s a number of books on Stalin in that stack – and few, if any, on Christian love.”

“Mohler doesn’t want to be humble servants as Jesus taught them to be they want to be powerful dictators in the guise of servant leaders.”

Again, just a small sampling of comments that get liked, applauded, laughed at, encouraged, agreed with, promoted by the other commenters and even the two blog leaders themselves.  [And these are some of the waaaaay more benign ones] For this small reason, as well as many more numerous ones which relate to public behavior and harassments, I find that they are hurting and damaging in a lot of ways the reputation they seek to cultivate, and the Christ-likeness they would seek to be known as. I would encourage them to examine this more closely and see  if they can’t do better, and be more loving, more gracious, more willing to assume the best of people even when they do act badly and even whom they disagree with.

25 thoughts on “A Small Sampling of the Wartburg Watch Combox Regarding Al Mohler

    • Vitriol?!! They’re quotes! I have been in fact trying to be able to read TWW but after the first couple of hours I have been blocked — for a couple of weeks — though the site operators say that they are not deliberately blocking me but their blocking service is automatically blocking me. I’m on this site because I’m trying to investigate the side of Christian life in which people are used like rags and then discarded, which is pretty much the whole extent of my nearly forty years of being a Christian and attending church.

      As far as the argued character assassinations that are mentioned in this thread goes, does anyone on this site see anything wrong with becoming multi-millionaires while purporting to be following the path and in the footsteps of Christ? And by using the spiritual gifts that God gave them to minister to the saints for personal gain?

  1. OMG are you for real? You just created a blog post to do exactly what you are accusing others of doing. To do what? Warn other people not to do what you are doing. Is that really what God called you to do? Maybe I will create a blog to write about you and how un Christ-like I think you are. Really!!!!

  2. On Deb’s “About” page:
    –She has often referred to herself as a “professional volunteer” because she has spent countless hours volunteering at her daughters’ school, leading a Moms in Touch prayer group, serving as a Girl Scout leader, leading ladies’ Bible studies, etc–

    Yikes. Her daughter went to government school, and she was a Girl Scout leader?
    I thought she was supposed to be discerning…

  3. To Stephanstrategy:
    Yes, my comments are very serious. The very worst site is actually mennoknight, an arrogant piece of excrement and trash that should be deleted immediately. However, its author continues spew garbagey essays day after day. The mennoknight site’s greatest influence is JMac, a terrible theologian who should be silenced in his theological community. Another terrible influence is A. Mohler of the fundamentalist school SBTS. Even worse is TMS, an awful school that demands belief in the six-day hilarity!

  4. Hi, Dustin. Just curious about a few things…

    Who are some that you would consider your “Christian heroes” (apart form Al Mohler, apparently).


    “…but they are almost exclusively known for their character assassinations and the murder of the reputations of Godly men and women.”

    Dee and Deb are known “almost exclusively” as character assassins? Known by whom, exactly? The only ones I’ve heard call them that are you, and various trolls.

  5. Great comments and blog- cant say enough bad things about WW- tow miserable women- like most women they don’t know what they want- but are quick to judge all authority and men today. Neo-Feminist would be a better label for both of them

    • I’m glad you appreciate my comments. As you can see this site remains the second worst site on the internets after mennoknight. I demand that you never view this insipid site again.

      • What does gnagl! mean? At first I honestly thought you were adding for emphasis the sound you choked out in frustration and anger as you finished your typing. But then I thought is might be an acronym in all lower case. What does gnagl! mean?

  6. The girls wrote a post about Mark Dever’s Church; Capitol Baptist and their membership contracts.

    Here are some of the commenter’s views expressed. It isn’t pretty
    CHBC process abuse
    Maheny hid behind Dever’s skirts
    Self important men on power trips
    Money talks in this crowd a gospel centered bribe
    Look at Carolyn Mahaney..look at what she has published. Nuff said
    Jonathan Leeman have your personally done a gospel centered execution
    Thank God for freedom of religion or they’d have you on the rack.
    Mark Dever, smoothest of the Neo-Cals, like a serpent, in a garden , talking about fruit
    Evangelical industrial complex
    When Mark Dever and Jonathan Leeman start to burn dissidents at the stake…
    Heavy handed authoritarian preachers
    They do judge…and claim they hold the keys to the kingdom of authority and declare who is in and who is out.
    They weep crocodile tears as they bite you on the behind.
    The wisdom of Hollywood creations are quoted: Voldemort, Comrade O’Brien, and Capt Mal Reynolds.

    It’s like dealing with a personality disorder individual
    Pompous words from power loving men
    CHBC behavior found to be pushy obnoxious and weird
    Only thing missing sacred underwear, temples and blood atonement
    9 Marks church “roach motel.”
    Papal infallibility
    Ding bat Pastors
    Gospel centered blackmail
    Obsessed with having power and authority
    It’s ALL about control
    You were predestined by God as His seshul Pet to rule over others.
    Utter disregard for the authority of the text of Scripture.
    Blood atonement will have to wait until they take back American and establish a truly Christina Nation. They all bets are off and you can never fill too many mass graves

    Soulless jackals
    Unwholesome behaviors
    Obsessive leaders
    Russell Moore is making an idol in the image of man
    The leaders don’t understand how close they are to phallic worship
    Lemming thought, spiritual abuse
    Dever and Mahaney want to cuddle and be best friends
    Spiritual Stalins
    ( They’re ) All about personal power, gain and ultimately fraud.

    We don’t need spiritual Stalins, Mao’s or Idi Amins who look at their position for personal gain for themselves and their friends.


    • Dear Phillip,

      I glanced through the comments above, and yes, they are harsh. They also happen to be quite accurate descriptions of pretty much every pastor and pastoral assembly I’ve ever been associated with. If Jesus could be so angry at the spiritual leaders, the scribes and the pharisees, of His day (at least He didn’t physically abuse them, like with a whip or anything inappropriate like that) what would He see differently today? Or what rather what does He see differently today? Would His criticisms be largely the same? Wouldn’t he be just as harsh? And if He whipped those who turned His Father’s house into a place of merchandise, how much more would He whip those who do the very same today to His Body?

  7. Awesome blog you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of any community forums that cover the same topics
    talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of
    group where I can get comments from other
    knowledgeable people that share the same interest. If you have any
    recommendations, please let me know. Cheers!
    – ABC102D.

  8. Never believe a man who says I’ll save you, but you have to pay me ten bucks. Never believe a man who says I’ll counsel you if you get down on your knees and worship me. Never trust a man who says I know more than you, are more spiritual than you, are more wise than you, and more righteous than you, and then tells you to pay him 10% of your salary for life. Never trust a man who says, “I have the pulpit and the bank account, so what are you gonna do to me? Nothing!”

    Never trust a man who is planning on running off with the money, or who plans to take the congregation away, or who is dating the church secretary secretly, or who places himself as a mediator between you and God. There is NO MEDIATOR BETWEEN MAN AND GOD BUT CHRIST JESUS. Anyone who says he is your mediator, is a thief.

  9. “…for the most part personal attacks and insults often go unchecked and are seemingly actively encouraged. The commenters will give long, rambling detailed psychoanalysis of anyone who they feel deserve it, often by excoriating their motives and speculating and ascribing intent heaped on with snarky and angry assertions. In many ways it strikes me as a toxic environment…”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s